Assimilation of Native Americans Into Society Essay

How different would be the sensation of a philosophic mind to reflect that instead of exterminating a part of the hu man race by our modes of population that we had perseve rose-cheeked th bouldered all difficulties and at last had imparted our K nary(prenominal)ledge of cultivating and the arts, to the Aboriginals of the bucolic by which the source of future spirit and happiness had been preserved and ext stop. unless it has been conceived to be impracticable to civilize the Indians of North America This opinion is believably more convenient than just. (Henry Knox to George Washington 1970s) Since the founding of The United States of America, the complication of dealing with the indigenous primordial Americans has been prevalent. The opening quotation emphasizes the approximation that our fathers grappled over what to do with the Indians since the founding of our country. Post colonial era primaeval Americans were discriminated against in a battle defined by the uninfect ed man versus the red man.As American settlers and institutions expanded west contendd, the Indians were pu strike down aside not except by containing them in reservations only when were a good deal disregarded as Americans from the civilized and improve tweed American. These prejudices even came from far up the totem pole in Washington. The political relation in the 19th century American Government regarding the indigenous muckle were defined by an era of the Americanization of the inherent American sight.This analytic research paper will address the issue of Native American engrossment and display how the efforts make by the American Government failed to shed a positive light on the indigenous mess. It will in same(p) manner explore the founding of specific instills for Indian children, namely the Carlisle Indian industrial School for Native Americans. The school was intended to integrate Indian children into western society by educating them and transforming their cultural beliefs.Although founder Richard Henry Pratt had good intentions for the school, it ended up doing more destruction to the Indians than success assimilating them into American society. onwards the assimilation of Indians can be full understood, the history of the segregation of the red man must be established. Before the Civil War it had been realizable to imagine that Indians and whites could remain permanently separate from on another The subject area census of this duration was that the minority ethnic groups did not belong in the same category as the Americans, and that they should remain a separate existence.The frequent idea was that separation was the easier and safe way to deal with the ethnic differences kind of than entering into a group conflict. Native Americans were easier to separate into cultural groupings, because they were the ones who chose to do so. Blacks, Irish, and Native Americans alike, Hoxie asserts, In this compartmentalized society, minorit y groups wel stimulated the opportunity to be socially isolated and culturally autonomous. As the whites expanded westward eventually towards atomic number 20 and Oregon, the separation between the two ethnic groups would no longer be possible.The natives, who once claimed the North American continent as their own, were different from the stimulus generalisation of Americans. They were known as the others. Eventually, with the help of the Indian Removal Act of 1830, the Indians were pushed choke to the west and on that point was a line known as the Indian frontier. This reach came with a promise that the white man would not desire this land for generations. But as the nation expanded, the indigenous people were forced onto smaller and smaller reservations, which restricted them economically.They were mostly restricted from pabulum and other resources. Brenda J. Child emphasizes this in her book Boarding School Seasons as she makes claims that the Ojibwe once made a lucrative profit farming rice, but were left with a fair amount of swampland after their apportionings had been madeFew Nett Lakers were able to book adequate gardens, but traditionalistic subsistence activities, tourism, and off reservation labor maintained the band. As the struggle to maintain their niche increased, Indians would either harbour to conform to society, or they would be depleted by it.The early relationship between Indians and whites was defined more like a war than the whites trying to work the Indians into society. Indian territories were often viewed as their own sovereign states rather than occupied American territory. Treaties were often concur upon in order to separate the red man from the white. Humanitarians believed that separation would abbreviate the level of violence on the frontier and provide Indians with enough time to become civilized However, the civilization of Indians into American society would not breathe on its own once the ethnic groups were se parated.Political action groups such(prenominal)(prenominal) as the Friends of the Indian were formed. These groups as intimately as organization officials started to interpolate their beliefs into those that the American Indians should be assimilated. Paul Prucha mentions in the introduction of his book that government officials and well meaning humanitarians and missionaries had had a hand in the operation and had sought-after(a) the welfare of the Indians in their attempts to civilize and Christianize them, bringing them into conformity with the patterns of life that marked the white existence. The goal of these advocates was not only to destroy the Indian and and the American but more importantly they sought the beau ideal that assimilated Native Americans would be proof that America was an open society and that by gratifying the wishes of society they could acquire social equality. Henry L. Dawes was one of the large(p) bits leading the Indian policy reform in the 19th c entury.Dawes served in the United Government throughout his career he was a congressman, senator, and eventually chairman of the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs. He was an advocate for the allotment of land to the Indians, and the assimilation of the indigenous people into the non-Indian mainstream. He proposed the Dawes Act of 1887, which support Indians to farm by allotting the head of house 160 acres of land. The land was private property, and small portions of it could be shared with members of the family.Dawes held strong opinions for the assimilation of Indians into white mans society, as he proclaimed in a speech to an Indian reform group in 1884, it were worth season to consider whether we could not make something out of him, and for the first time in the whole history of our dealings with the Indians, within a few years, we move over attempted to make something out of him. In this speech he argues that the methods of waging war against the Indian has been failing, an d was taking the lives of both the Indian and the white man.Instead he proposes that they be assimilated, and that the Native Americans can be useful in society. He later touches on educating the Native American children, stating, Take him as you do other children, and bring him up as you do other children. procreation then becomes a major factor in the assimilating the Native American people. The Idea that targeting the younger generation of the Indian population and regulate them into the mold of an getd white man became prevalent in assimilation techniques.Education of the Indians was the ultimate reform An increase of immigrants from Europe reflected a ripening public support for education. Thus, if the children of the Indian were educated, they would catch on in American society and pave the way for future generations. Richard Henry Pratt was an outstanding figure in the Americanization of Native Americans. As a veteran of the Civil War, Pratt fought both alongside and aga inst Indian warriors. He was a proponent of educating the tribal people in order to kill the Indian, save the man.He was well aware of the capabilities of the Indian following his tour of duty with them on the battlefield. When the war was over, Pratt insisted that he took a group of Indian prisoners to Fort Marion in Florida and educate them as well as assimilating them into American culture. He had scarce success as he educated them in English, Christianity, art, and culture. What brought the success was that he found work for the Indians around the predominately white St. Augustine area.He interested white benefactors in his cause and stoopd his army superiors to assign him to the work of Indian education, where he could promote and expand the approach to Indian assimilation that he had begun so dramatically at fort Marion. Pratts motif was straightforward he wanted complete integration of the Indians into white society, and all of his actions were submitted towards that goal. His next project, The Carlisle Indian Industrial School, was by far his most famous and also polemical way of implementing Indians into society.His idea was to transform the abandoned Carlisle Military Barracks in Carlisle, pappa into a boarding school for Native Americans. It wasnt hard to persuade the government to jump on board with his idea, Said that the government was almost to adopt a new policy with the Indians that it believed the Indian youth sufficient of acquiring the same education and industries as our white youth However, it was comparatively difficult to persuade chiefs of various tribes to send their children away with Pratt.In his autobiography, Pratt tells a story nigh going out west to propose his idea to a chief named spotted tail and after his proposal he receives the response, We are not going to give any children to learn such ways Pratt refutes and claims that if it werent for the Indians ignorance and lack of education, the American Government would not be able to take advantage of the tribes if they were educated. The chiefs reconvened and after discussing decided to send their children. In a way, Pratt used slander to get the Indians to give up their children by telling them the kids would come back and contribute.However, Pratt did not want this, as his intentions were to fully integrate the red man into society. The Carlisle Boarding School was founded in 1879. It started with astir(predicate) a hundred Indians and over time expanded to about a thousand. It admitted both boys and girls. Upon arrival, students were required to disrobe from their native clothes and cut their hair. The cloths were garish, and Pratt mentions, It was the shoddiest of shoddy clothing. This was the first step towards the transformation to white culture. Although students were provided with an education, daily life was rough for students at Carlisle.Students had to wake early and drill. School schedules were grueling, and the students were often underfed. Sometimes the school seemed like more a labor camp as they were instructed to bring about tasks such as The authority came, and, directed by the carpenter, the Indian boys take the holes, set up the post, nailed on the rails and slats, and we soon had a self-colored barrier which remained a satisfactory protection during my superintendency. The school may have taught Indians mechanical and agricultural skills as well as providing an education, but it emphatically was not as successful as Pratt Envisioned.There were many successes in the founding of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School, but there were more mishaps. Advocates for boarding schools such as Pratt argued that the separation of Indian children from their families in combination of industrial training would reduce the tribalism in the individual. Brenda J. Child proposes, One of the worst ideas about how to best solve the Indian problem mandated the separation of American Indian families. Homesickness was extremely common in Indian boarding school students, and often led to the students back lashing against authority, or running away from the school. ailment and death was also a very unsafe problem at boarding schools. Crowded conditions are the perfect medium for the spread of disease. bantam pox, chicken pox, diphtheria, tuberculosis, and the common cold killed many of these children and crowding helped spread the diseases to the rest. Students with serious sicknesses were often sent home because if they died at the school, their reputation would be devastated. The problems seemed to outdo the advantages at boarding schools, and these factors contributed to the eventual dismissal of Richard Henry Pratt from the Superintendent position.Because Native Americans have always been distinctly different from the rest of society, efforts to assimilate Indians alone into society have been abandoned. There have still been assimilation efforts in the twentieth century, but the ideals beh ind them have changed. The effort to kill the Indian, save the man has been deemed impossible. Indian schools are successful in theory, but there is a reason that they failed and that Pratts unrealistic dream did not come true. Some argue that the efforts by reformers such as Dawes and Pratt were successful, but the true statement is that many failures come with successes.As George Washington states, When one side only of a story is heard and often repeated, the human mind becomes affect with it insensibly. Bibliography Primary Sources Pratt, Richard H. Battlefield and classroom four decades with the American Indian, 1867-1904. okay University of Oklahoma Press, 2004. Coleman, Michael C. American Indian Children at School, 1850-1930. n. d. Child, Brenda J. Boarding School Seasons American Indian Families, 1900-1940. Lincoln University of Nebraska Text, 1998. Hoxie, Frederick E. A Final Promise The Campaign To take over The Indians, 1880-1920.Cambridge Cambridge University Press, 1984. Prucha, Francis P. The groovy Father The United States Government and the American Indians. Vol. 2. N. p. University of Nebraska Text, 1984 Duran, Eduardo, and sightly Duran. Native American Postcolonial Psychology. Albany State University of New York Press, 1995. Prucha, Francis P. Americanizing the American Indians belles-lettres by the Friends of the Indian 1880-1900. Cambridge, Massachusetts Harvard University Press, 1973 Lee, John. studys of Indian Schools. Annual Report. Washington, D. C built in bed other Commissioner of Indian Affairs. From Library of Congress, American Indians of the Pacific Northwest. (1886) Leupp, Francis E. Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs. Annual Report. Washington, D. C Office of the Commissioner of Indian Affair. Library of Congress, American Indians of the Pacific Northwest (1908) Dawes, Henry L. Solving the Indian Problem. Fifteenth Annual Report of the Board of Indian Commissioners (1883) 69-70. Morgan, Thomas J. Supplem ental report on Indian Education. House Executive Document 1, no. 2 (n. d. ) 93-104. Schultz, Jeffrey D.Encyclopedia of Minorities in American Politics Volume 2, Hispanic Americans and Native Americans. Westport Greenwood Press, 2000. Secondary Holm, Tom. Great Confusion in Indian Affairs Native Americans and Whites in the modernized Era. Austin, TX University of Texas Press, 2005. Simonsen, Jane E. Making Home Work Domesticity and Native American Assimilation in the American West, 1860-1919. Chappel Hill UNC Press, 2006. authorsden. com . WHAT WERE BOARDING SCHOOLS LIKE FOR INDIAN YOUTH?. Hetzel, Theodore B. WE tummy LEARN FROM AMERICAN INDIANS. Journal of American Indian Education 4, no. 3 (1965)The Indian School at Chemawa. The West Shore 13, no. 1 (1887) 5-12. Davis, Julie. American Indian Boarding School Experiences Recent Studies from Native Perspectives. OAH Magazine of History Vol. 15, No. 2, 2001, 20-22. Fear-Segal, Jackie. Boarding School Seasons American Indian Families, 1900-1940 by Brenda J. Child. Journal of American Studies 34, no. 1 (2000) 160-161. Hoerig, Karl A. Remembering Our Indian School Days The Boarding School Experience. Away from Home American Indian Boarding School Experiences by Margaret L. Archuleta Brenda J. Child K. Tsianina Lomawaima (2002) 642-646.